Page 1 of 1

Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Fri Jul 22, 2016 4:54 pm
by Ezel
There is no way to tell its human...

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Fri Jul 22, 2016 4:59 pm
by InsaneHyena
Yes, it's funnier that way.

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Fri Jul 22, 2016 5:09 pm
by Atlanta-Ned
Ezel wrote:There is no way to tell its human...
SecHUDs still show job icons IIRC.

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Fri Jul 22, 2016 6:06 pm
by Ezel
Atlanta-Ned wrote:
Ezel wrote:There is no way to tell its human...
SecHUDs still show job icons IIRC.
Borgs have no sechuds

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Fri Jul 22, 2016 8:40 pm
by Zilenan91
They should unless they were removed with a stealth change.

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Sat Jul 23, 2016 4:07 pm
by Anonmare
I'll allow it on the condition that someone disguised as a borg sounds like they have silicon speech to them

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Sun Jul 24, 2016 4:08 am
by Armhulen
lizard with human tounge, hitting humans with a plant disguise. has human name. attack?

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Sun Jul 24, 2016 7:53 am
by Anonmare
I'd say yes it can, if the borg was ordered to since you shouldn't be killing non-Humans unless ordered to or in compliance of Law 1. A name's just a tag and doesn't really mean a lot to a borg or AI and if it sounds like a Lizard, looks like a plant then until you get a proof of Humanity - it's pretty safe to assume it's not Human.

Though if you're unsure of whether something is Human or not (like a Nuke OP covered up by their suit) then you should treat them as Human until proven otherwise.

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Sun Jul 24, 2016 7:53 pm
by Jacough
If whatever's disguised as a plant is actively trying to kill someone be he human or subhuman, I think it'd be hilarious to allow the borg to kill him as long as he maintains the belief that he's attacking a killer plant.

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2016 9:05 am
by callanrockslol
Anonmare wrote:I'd say yes it can, if the borg was ordered to since you shouldn't be killing non-Humans unless ordered to or in compliance of Law 1. A name's just a tag and doesn't really mean a lot to a borg or AI and if it sounds like a Lizard, looks like a plant then until you get a proof of Humanity - it's pretty safe to assume it's not Human.

Though if you're unsure of whether something is Human or not (like a Nuke OP covered up by their suit) then you should treat them as Human until proven otherwise.
Its never safe to assume its non-human if you don't want to break law 1.
Ezel wrote:There is no way to tell its human...
You have to definitely know its non-human before you can harm it and not break your laws, otherwise the odds are you are harming a human are pretty high given they make up most of the crew capable of dressing up as a borg/plant. Even hissing when they talk isn't a safe way to do it anymore given that you can transplant tongues.

Same issue with lings, if someone tells you its a ling but there isn't any evidence that it is then killing it is a good way to potentially harm a human, unless you catch them doing it or a bunch of people can confirm what happened you're in a shitty spot as an AI. Best to trap it forever surrounded by walls.

Re: Can a borg legit attack a potted plant/Cyborg disguise

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2016 11:51 am
by Davidchan
If doesn't look human it's not human. But you still can't just attack it because. If it's asimov

1) Does the Plant/Borg imposter causing harm or going to cause imminent harm?
2) Have you been ordered to attack it?
3) Does it threaten your exsistence.

It's basically the same thing as a monkified geneticist to me. OOC you KNOW it's human/lizard but it's in a non-human form so it's non human (like xenobio slime people). Once the disguise falls and they are revealed to be human you can't attack them further though.